Tag: customer service

  • Don’t Call When The Tatty Skies Catch On Fire

    I don’t mean to pile on United Airlines, but they do bring it on themselves sometimes. The latest TravelCommons podcast talks about how the “friendly skies” of United Airlines have become a bit thread worn — duct tape holding together armrests, seat backs that can’t stay up (which was my experience again on my Monday flight from ORD to SFO). Not surprising since United is the only major US airline without any current orders placed for new aircraft.

    Two new news stories illustrate United’s slide. Scanning the front page of yesterday’s Chicago Tribune while sitting forward in my auto-recline seat, I saw an article about a women whose luggage was burned by United.

    As Shannon Tadel waited in the Syracuse, N.Y., airport for her flight back to Chicago on Dec. 1, a United Airlines employee approached her and asked if he could speak to her privately.

    “He said, ‘Your luggage has been set on fire,’” Tadel recounted later. “I kind of chuckled at him because it was so unbelievable. I was like, ‘Um, OK.’”The employee explained that her bag, containing most of her wardrobe, had been placed too close to the exhaust of a belt loader used to deliver bags to the cargo hold. Someone turned on the equipment and, voila, luggage flambe.

    A dumbfounded Tadel boarded the plane, not quite sure what to do. Moments later, the pilot summoned her to the cockpit.

    “He said, ‘Do you see that over there? That’s your luggage,’” Tadel recalled.

    She looked out the plane’s window and saw a man with a hose and a big plume of smoke.

    Tadel says she filed a claim on December 4 and didn’t receive a check from United until last week — after she got the Tribune’s What’s Your Problem columnist involved.

    And then comes the story of United’s announcement yesterday that they are closing their complaints call center, telling customers to send a letter or an e-mail instead. United said the reason for this move is to improve customer satisfaction — “We did a lot of research, we looked into it, and people who email or write us are more satisfied with our responses,” said United spokesperson Robin Urbanski. But this is also a cost-cutting move — managing written inquiries is easier and costs less than taking phone calls.

    It’s also another push toward self-service — putting the burden of writing up the issue/complaint on the customer rather than having an United employee take if from a phone conversation. In TravelCommons #71, I said “The duct tape holding together the tatty skies are the employees,” that in spite of all the management mistakes, most of the United employees are doing a good job in serving their customers. Yet this latest move by United continues a trend of separating customers from employees — book your tickets on-line, use a kiosk to check in, and now send an e-mail if you have a problem. I can’t wait until they try to replace flight attendants with vending machines.

  • In Case You Thought It Would Change Anytime Soon

    Today’s Chicago Tribune gave front page coverage to a US Department of Transportation consumer forum on air travel. The story’s title, You Are Now Free To Take A Flying Leap, says it all. The reporter’s conclusion is disheartening realistic — “airline passengers received an unapologetic warning at the forum that customer service will continue to diminish and consumers more than ever need to fend for themselves at the airport”. The airlines’ ever expanding set of nickel-and-diming fees are less about generating additional revenue and more about cost reduction — reducing the demand for services that aren’t directly associated with keeping a jet in the air. American Airlines’ $15 charge for the first checked bag is really all about reducing fuel costs — incenting passengers to bring less luggage, reducing fuel consumption through reduced load weight.

    Comparing passenger jets to “flying buses” is not an exaggeration. The airlines are redefining themselves, shrinking the boundaries of their responsibilities. They no longer sell a travel experience; they sell transport. And they’re walking running away from any service that doesn’t directly involve transporting passengers through the air. Is this a business opportunity for another company — say, for one of the private airport operating companies? Hmmm, not sure the result will be any better if BAA’s stewardship of London Heathrow is any guide. The real question, though — are regular coach passengers willing to pay for anything more than being hauled from one city to another?

  • Podcast #55 – True Cost of Connecting; See More With The Family

    Recorded in the Marriott Courtyard in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, the current “blogstorm” about United Airlines’ poor customer service provides the data to calculate the true cost of connecting flights. A recent combined business and family trip to New York City makes me realize that my family isn’t a burden in my travels, but instead an eyeopener. Listeners comment on my recent blog posts; one uses Twitter to report his hotel broadband speed test results. Here’s a direct link to the podcast file.


    Here are the show notes from TravelCommons podcast #55:

    • Intro music — Warmth by Makkina
    • Recorded in Marriott Courtyard in Chapel Hill, NC
    • Been on a weekly commute to San Francisco, though did get in a combo business/family trip to New York the week before last
    • Have had very few problems flying to the Bay Area, but this last flight back from LaGuardia had us sitting on the runway for 3 hours
    • Bridge Music — Did We Make It by Casey Desmond
    • Drew Leifheit of the Budacast podcast recounts a fond childhood memory of eating pecan pie while flying Delta with his grandmother
    • John F corrects Barbara Higgins’ (United Airlines’ VP of customer experience) confusion between proactive and reactive customer service
    • Daniel Perez of the Gamer Traveler Podcast is surprised to see US TSA agents in Amsterdam’s Schipol Airport
    • Mika Pyyhkala has been twittering his Speakeasy broadband speed tests
    • Steve Frick of the Frick’s World blog has inspired me to take pictures out my hotel room window and add them to Flickr’s View From Here collection
    • Bridge Music — Throwing up on the plane by Electromagnetic Impulses
    • Recent TravelCommons blog posts on United Airlines customer service got looped into the edge of a growing “blogstorm”
    • Articles in the Chicago Tribune and USAToday have fueled the storm
    • The May 14th entry in the Briana’s Random Access Babble blog gives a detailed account of her efforts to fly from New York to Las Vegas to visit her family for the weekend; also a detailed accounting of her out-of-pocket costs caused by missed flight connections in Denver
    • We use Briana’s cash outlay figures to calculate the true cost of a connecting flight
    • Leo Vegoda’s recent missed connection experience in Washington’s Dulles airport validates the findings reported in an International Herald Tribune article that says FAA flight delay statistics grossly understate the actual passenger delays
    • Bridge Music — Ghost by Hollow Horse
    • I don’t seem to have to “downshift” as much anymore when traveling with my family
    • Traveling with my daughter has bumped me out of my usual rut
    • Closing music — iTunes link to Pictures of You by Evangeline
    • Bridge music from the Podsafe Music Network
    • Feedback at comments[at]travelcommons.com, the comment board on podcastalley.com, or right here in the comments section below
    • Direct link to the show
  • United’s Customer Service in a Free Fall

    The drumbeat of complaints regarding United Airline’s deteriorating customer service continues. In the Trade Your Bags For Another $1/Hr post, I mentioned the results of the recent University of Michigan customer satisfaction survey. If the satisfaction index for the airline industry in general plummeted — they’re now just barely ahead of the IRS — then the score for United Airlines did a free-fall, landing at the bottom of the list. TravelCommons got looped into an edge of this growing blogstorm. Our last post, commenting on the Chicago Tribune story about the weekend-long ordeal of United passengers trying to get home from Jamaica, was picked up by a UCLA law professor who then linked over to last week’s USAToday article titled “United passengers air their bitter grievances”. The article lists an incredible litany of complaints.

    Things only got worse last week when an IT tester took down United’s entire operations system, stranding most of their fleet Wednesday morning. I was flying from San Francisco (SFO) to Chicago (ORD) that evening and felt lucky that my flight arrived only 50 minutes late. Two days later, I received a fairly bland e-mail apology from United’s Vice-President of Customer Experience Barbara Higgins:

    Dear Mark A Peacock,

    On behalf of United, I want to express our sincere regrets for any disruption to service you may have experienced when flying with us on Wednesday and Thursday this week. We know you expect us to take you where you want to go with on-time departures and arrivals. We failed to meet your expectations on those days.

    As you may be aware, a computer outage, due to human error during routine system testing, significantly impacted our operations systemwide. Working as a team, we were able to get our airplanes and crews back on schedule … and our passengers on their way.

    We greatly appreciated your patience and know that we will make every effort to keep this type of situation from occurring in the future.

    Your satisfaction and business mean a great deal to United, and we look forward to our next opportunity to serve you.

    Sincerely,

    Barbara Higgins
    Vice-President
    Customer Experience
    United Airlines

    I compare this to the impassioned, heartfelt apology over the PA from the lead flight attendant on my SFO-ORD flight. Obviously exhausted by a long day, his voice cracked as he thanked us for “hanging in there” on what was a “helluva” day. The whole crew lined up and thanked each passenger as we left the plane.

    Though I’ve had more than my share of rude gate agents and flight attendants, this episode reinforced my sense that the cause of United’s (and American’s and Northwest’s) customer service woes lies with those employees and managers who never see a passenger — the ones who can hide by ignoring ringing phones and full e-mail boxes. An article in Monday’s Wall Street Journal talks about the impact of training programs that require executives to perform front-line jobs. I’d like to see Ms Higgins roll up her sleeves and clean up the backlog of ticket refunds mentioned by so many passengers interviewed in the USAToday article, or help find some lost luggage, or help work some of those concourse-long lines that appear when United’s delays and cancellations force people to miss their flights. Perhaps some front-line experience would incent her and her colleagues to fix United’s mess rather than send me their generic apologies.

  • Podcast #54 – Traveling Injured; How Bad Is Travel Experience Really?

    Recorded in the Grand Geneva Resort and Spa, the former Playboy Club, in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, I talk about the travails of “playing injured” — traveling while sick. A listener comment makes me wonder if I’m exaggerating the state of the US travel experience. We get a good suggestion on how to wrestle with charging all those electronic devices we carry, and some detailed “behind-the-scenes” explanations of how air crews are treated by the TSA. Here’s a direct link to the podcast file.


    Here are the show notes from TravelCommons podcast #54:

    • Intro music — Warmth by Makkina
    • Recorded in Grand Geneva Resort and Spa in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin
    • Been on the road every week since my last podcast, mostly here in San Francisco
    • Bridge Music — Hejm by The Headroom Project
    • Thanks to everyone who told me that the podcast had been gone too long
    • Craig Martin of the Indie Travel Podcast sends along an audio comment with a great suggestion on how to avoid the “outlet congestion” I mentioned in TC #53
    • I’ve found that for most electrical devices, you don’t even need the power converter, just the plug adapter
    • Received two good answers to my question in TC#53 as to why an Oakland TSA screener allowed a Southwest flight attendant to keep her shoes going through the metal detector
    • This USAToday article suggests that airline and airport employees will face greater security measures as a result of the foiled JFK plot
    • Bridge Music — Electric Butterfly by Falik
    • All travel inconveniences pale when compared to getting sick or injured while traveling
    • Two weeks ago, I injured my back the morning before a flight to San Francisco
    • Worse was the experience of getting food poisoning in Lyon, France and still having to carry on with business the next day
    • Bridge Music — Snake Eyes by Seismic Anomaly
    • An e-mail exchange with Udayan Tripathi got me to wondering if I exaggerate the problems with US domestic travel
    • The TSA isn’t the most charming group, but they’re no worse than the screeners in London’s Heathrow airport
    • A USAToday article this week reported that the number of passenger complaints to US Dept of Transportation in April about bad airline service had doubled from the year before
    • The service from US legacy carriers is worse than in other parts of the world, but the new US carriers (e.g., JetBlue) offer better service than legacy or budget carriers elsewhere
    • Closing music — iTunes link to Pictures of You by Evangeline
    • Bridge music from Magnatune
    • Feedback at comments[at]travelcommons.com, the comment board on podcastalley.com, or right here in the comments section below
    • Direct link to the show